Homeopathy Tips for 11/9/10 Caring Too Much

Is it possible to care too much for your client? I believe it is and see it happen to some of my students as they begin to manage cases. Caring too much can lead to lack of clarity as well as ill health on the part of the practitioner. Let me explain more.

Often we make emotional ties to our clients especially if we like them. Some people we are drawn to in a personal way even though they are our clients. This is a natural response to another human being. There can be great affinity for another. Other clients we do not make the same emotional bonds with and it seems a little easier, even if Hahnemann warned us to be unprejudiced observers. It is prejudice to have any feelings beyond empathy. Sympathy is to have feelings that are similar to the person you are in sympathy with. To feel these it is usually because they trigger a similar hurt that we carry in ourselves.

When we are in sympathy with another we have lost our clarity. We are now experiencing our own emotional response. We need clarity and distance to be able to see the case before us. If we do not have this we might as well be prescribing for ourselves.

Caring too much can also makes us the healer by default. If our care  does not include giving all outcomes back to a divine will, then our ego is attached to the outcome of our desire. This is a setup for more emotional pain in the practitioner. This pain will again keep us locked into an expected outcome and when  the case does not proceed as we think it should; we will have lost clarity. All healing is between the person and G-d. We are practitioners under the guidance of a divine energy that is operating through all creation. By recognizing this, we are merely a tool for the divine. We are responsible for our actions, but not for the outcome. This brings us to be very responsible as our role as homeopath, but not as healer.

Caring too much can take it’s toll on the practitioner. Over time I have seen others burn out, including myself, when the demands of our work keep us from taking good care of ourselves. Remember the maxim, physician, heal thyself. I think this is one of the most important things to remember when taking care of others. We must not loose sight of our own health in the process. It can happen easier than we might think.

Symptoms of caring too much can lead to anxiety, worry, sleeplessness, fear, resentment, and many other ways of suffering  particular to the individual. Eventually the practitioner will want to give up. The returns on the energy expended will not be enough to continue. This is the burn out stage and the practitioner needs a rest and some distance to come back to clarity.

Rubrics from the Complete 2009 Repertory to consider when caring becomes too much are;

  • Mind; ANXIETY; Others, for (77) : acet-ac., 3Acon., aeth., androc., 3Arg-n., 3Ars., aur., 3Aur-m-n., 3Aur-s., bar-c., borag., calc-ar., calc-m., 3Calc-p., calc-s., calc-sil., carb-an., carb-v., 2carc., catha-e., 3Caust., chel., cocc., corv-c., culx-p., cupr., cyg-c., 3Dulc., falco-p., 3Ferr., ferr-p., fl-ac., germ., helod-c., hep., herin., ign., lac-del., lac-eq., lac-h., lach., lamp-c., 2lap-be-e., latex, leon., lsd, 3Manc., mand., merc., methylp-h., musca-d., naja, nat-c., nelu., nitro., 3Nux-v., onc-t., perh., perla, petr., ph-ac., 3Phos., phys., polyst., puls., 4RHUS-T., ros-ca-a., sac-alb., scorp., sep., 3Spig., 3Staph., 3Sulph., taosc., 2tax-br., uran-n., zinc.
  • Mind; SYMPATHETIC, compassionate (110) : acon., adam., aeth., 2aids, alco., aloe, alum-s., am-c., ambr., ana-i., androc., arg-n., arn., aur., 3Aur-m-n., aur-s., bac., bani-c., bar-c., bar-p., bell., beryl., 2bos-s., calc., 3Calc-p., cand-a., caras., 3Carc., carl., 3Caust., cench., chin., chir-f., 3Cic., clad-r., cocc., coloc., corv-c., croc., cupr., cypra-e., dros., 3Dulc., enal-c., ephe., 3Falco-p., ferr-p., garden., germ., gins., graph., haliae-lc., harp., hell., helod-c., hydrog., 3Ign., ilx-p., iod., kola., lac-f., lac-leo., lac-lup., lach., lamp-c., 2lepro., lim-b-c., loxo-r., lsd, lyc., 3Lyss., mag-c., manc., mand., med., melal-l., merc., micro-a., mosch., 3Nat-c., 3Nat-m., 2nic-r., 3Nit-ac., nuph., 3Nux-v., oci-s., onc-t., oxyg., 4PHOS., plut-n., posit., pter-a., puls., pyrit., querc-r., ros-ca-a., ros-d., ros-g., salx-f., scorp., sep., seq-s., 3Staph., stram., tarent., tax., teg-a., tub., ulm-c., uran-n.
  • Mind; WEEPING, tearful mood; Sympathy for others, from (11) : bar-c., carc., carl., caust., falco-p., lyc., mand., nit-ac., puls., ros-ca-a., sep.
  • Mind; SYMPATHY, compassion; Ailments from, agg. (28) : aego-p., arg., 3Arn., ars., 3Bell., bufo, cact., 3Calc., carb-ac., cham., clem., coff., con., hell., 4IGN., kali-s., lil-t., musa, 4NAT-M., 3Plat., polyst., posit., sabal., sep., 3Sil., sulph., syph., toxop-p.
  • Generalities; WEAKNESS; Nursing the sick, from (9) : carb-v., 3Cimic., 4COCC., 3Nit-ac., 3Nux-v., olnd., puls., zinc., 3Zinc-ar.
  • Mind; ANXIETY; Nightwatching, after (6) : aur., caust., 3Cocc., cupr., 4NIT-AC., nux-v.
  • Mind; ANXIETY; Future, about (169) : acon., adam., aego-p., aeth., agar., alco-s., allox., 3Aloe, 3Alum., alum-p., aml-n., 3Anac., anan., 3Ant-c., 3Ant-t., aquilr-a., arg-n., arist-cl., arn., 3Ars., astac., aster., aur., 3Aur-m-n., 3Aur-s., 3Bamb-a., 3Bar-c., 3Bar-m., bar-s., beryl., bros-g., 4BRY., bufo, buth-aust., calad., 4CALC., calc-acet., 3Calc-ar., calc-f., calc-p., calc-s., carb-an., carb-v., 2carc., 2cassi-s., 4CAUST., cham., 3Chel., 3Chin., 4CHIN-S., chir-f., choc., chrysan., 4CIC., cimic., cinis-p., clem., cocc., coff., 3Con., conch., culx-p., cupr., curc., cycl., 2cyg-c., 3Dig., dirc., 3Dros., 3Dulc., 3Euph., euphr., falco-p., ferr., ferr-acet., ferr-c., 3Ferr-p., fl-ac., fum., 3Gels., germ., gins., 3Graph., grat., harp., hell., hep., hipp., hura, 3Iod., kali-br., 2kali-c., kali-m., kali-p., kalm., kola., lac-leo., 3Lach., 2lap-be-e., lar-ar., lat-h., laur., lil-t., lith-c., lsd, lyc., 3M-arct., mag-c., mang., mant-r., meny., merc., methylp-h., 3Mur-ac., nat-acet., nat-ar., 3Nat-c., 4NAT-M., nat-p., nat-s., nelu., 3Nit-ac., nitro., 3Nux-v., onc-t., 3Op., ozone, parth., perla, 4PETR., 3Ph-ac., 4PHOS., plat., psor., 3Puls., querc-r., ran-b., 3Rhus-t., 3Sabin., scroph-n., scut., 3Sep., 3Sil., sol, sol-t-ae., spect., 3Spig., 4SPONG., 3Stann., 3Staph., stram., stront-c., sul-ac., 4SULPH., tab., taosc., tarent., tax., telo-s., 3Thuj., tub., ulm-c., 2vanil., verat., vichy-g., vichy-h., viol-t., wies., xan.

There are a few remedies worth noting for when the practitioner has cared too much and is is now suffering. These I have found to be most useful;

  • Carcinosin – When there is too much concern that has left the person a bit vacant. Weeping with sympathy. Loves the excitement of a thunderstorm. Looks like a combination of many different remedies.
  • Causticum – The “cause to come” When the cause becomes bigger than the person can manage successfully. Paralysis, either physical or mental. Brain fag. Forgetful.
  • Cimicifuga – When the pattern of energy is like a chicken with it’s head cut off. Always another fire to put out.
  • Cocculus – After loosing much sleep, either to taking care of others or worrying about them.
  • Nitric Acid – When resentment has set in and the lack of care is the result. A truly burned out state.
  • Pulsatilla Nigricans – When there is much weeping. When the emotions loose control often and weeping is the result.

It is not cold-hearted to be unsympathetic. It is actually not a good place for the practitioner to be in sympathy with their client. They will not have clarity. Having empathy is much healthier. This will include the capacity to care without having an emotional response to it. Then we have not lost our center to an emotional response and can really show up for our client. We will not have to suffer ourselves because we care inappropriately for our client. Eventually caring too much will take it’s toll on us and we will eventually either burn out or become ill ourselves. Then we are not much help to our clients.

So take good care of yourselves. Care about your role as the practitioner. Do good work. And leave the rest to G-d. All things are possible and our trust of this equals our faith in the healing powers of homeopathy.

15 comments so far

  1. Peter Bezemek on

    Very true! Thanks for an interesting article, Robert!

    Take care,

  2. jayanti on

    very true and i got to read the column when i am actually going through this.

  3. Dilip Patra, on

    This article has reminded me of the age old hindu maxim that suggests to be like a drop of water on the leaves of lotus. so be part of the people you are required to care for but at the same time be above the personal or emotional attachment with them, that might not be good for the health of both – the physician and the patient. Hoping for more of such inspiring articles. Dilip.

  4. Shankar Chawla on

    Over caring can at times be suffocating even for patients as we forget to keep space.

  5. Shirley on

    This rings so true to me currently and as a life long lesson.
    It bears constant reminding from ourselves and others, that we are not at the end but a conduit toward true healing.
    Thank you for speaking about the shadow of suffering in the healer and what needs to be exposed to the light.


  6. Bilal Ahmad on

    One of my colleagues who is doing his MD often suffers from symptoms of the patients being treated by him. If he is treating a pt. with nephritis – thinks himself to be suffering from the same disease. When he treats a pt. with malignancy and carcinoma, he starts feeling the problems in himself.He is an allopath Dr. How can I help him in this.

    • Robert Field on

      Hello Bilal, Look at the remedy Phosphorus. It is compassionate and too open. It may be helpful.

  7. Asghar Ali on

    The doctor treats and HE(Almighty ALLAH) cures. Our attachment towards our clients shall be to the extent of offering best of the remedy.

  8. Robert Lal on

    A good piece of suggestion! Over caring can at times lead to more complex problems. Thanks Dr. Robert Field

  9. dr pritanjali on

    very good suggetion because these kind of notes we never find in books….but is very important point to be followed in clinics……….thanks pritanjali

  10. Dr.Kh Mahbubur Rahman on

    Dear Robert,

    “All healing is between the person & G-d.We are
    practioners under the guidence of a divine energy….
    We are merely a tool for the divine.We are responsible
    for our actions,but not for the outcome.This brings us
    to be very responsible as Homeopath,but not as healer.

    Again,”Remember the maxim,physician heal thyself.”

    Really,wonderful.What an insight!You are a great teacher,
    Robert.Thank you very much for the article & focusing
    such divine light on our way of thinking.

    In this connection,could please inform the name of any
    medicine which has anxiety or excitement felt on
    completion of a task like sleeplessnes for some hours at

    Dr.Mahbubur Rahman,Dhaka,Bangladesh.

    • Robert on

      Hello Dr,

      Possibly the remedy coffea tosta may be useful. It is useful for any excitement leading to sleeplessness.


  11. iqra mughal on

    its a very important article n in our modern life …………. very interesting.

  12. Dr.Kh.Mahbubur Rahman on


    Thank you very much for your reply dated
    17th November 2010.It is helpful,no doubt.
    Is there any other medicine which has excitement
    for some hours on completion of a task?

    Kh.Mahbubur Rahman

  13. sara gaviria on

    el articulo muy interesante pues nosotros somos solo un intermediario de energia y le paciente con nuestra buen sentir sanara

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: